Jobs Board
Log In Become a Member
Knowledge Exchange UK
Jobs Board
Log In Become a Member
  • Home
  • Membership
    • hidden – do not delete
  • Learn & Develop
    • hidden – do not delete
  • Events
    • hidden – do not delete
  • News
    • Member News
  • Resources
    • hidden – do not delete
  • Home
  • Membership
    • Why Join Us?
    • Become a member
    • Members Directory
  • Learn & Develop
    • Book a course
    • In-House Training
  • Events
    • Conference
    • KE Awards
    • Directors’ Forum
    • Online Events
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Reports
    • Webinars
  • About
    • About Us
    • Brand Guidelines
    • Work with us
    • What is Knowledge Exchange?
  • KE Concordat
    • About
    • The 8 Guiding Principals
  • Jobs Board
  • Social Ventures and SHAPE
Log In Become a Member
Membership
Join our community of knowledge exchange professionals and access exclusive resources, events, and networking opportunities.
Become a member
Be part of our community
Why Join Us?
Become a member
Renew your membership
Members Directory
Member Events
Online Community
Communities & Groups
Resources
Browse our resources for blogs, news articles and all the information, advice and support you need in knowledge exchange and commercialisation.
View all resources
Media
News Articles
Blogs
Webinars
Reports
Topic Hubs
KE Concordat
KE Matters
AI
Government
Funding
Inclusion and diversity
Knowledge Exchange
Technology Transfer
Intellectual Property
SHAPE
Spinouts
Sustainability
Events
Join our networking events, including annual conference, KE Awards, Directors' Forum, and a variety of member-only gatherings.
View our events
Conference
Overview
Abstracts
Sponsorship
KE Awards
Attend
Finalists
Supporters & Sponsors
Judging Panel
Events
All Events
Directors' Forum
KE Matters
Learn & Develop
Continue your professional development with our training courses, workshops, and tailored in-house training designed to enhance your skills and knowledge.
Find out more
Our Courses
Fundamentals of Technology Transfer
Research Contracts
Practical Business Development
Spinout Creation
Software Commercialisation
Negotiation for Knowledge Exchange Professionals
Commercialisation in Healthcare
Establishing and Growing a Successful TTO
Practical Licensing
Developing Strategic Partnerships
New to Knowledge Exchange Programme
Leadership in Knowledge Exchange
Knowledge Exchange for Academics
Fundamentals of IP
CPD Opportunities
Book onto a training course
In-House Training
Mentoring
Become a volunteer
Apply for RTTP

Contact Us

+44 (0)1223 776130
info@ke.org.uk

St John's Innovation Centre
Cowley Rd,
Milton,
Cambridge,
CB4 0WS

Follow Us

Content Category: Government

Home > Government

Speakers include Celia Caulcott (Executive Director, Innovation and Skills, BBSRC and RCUK); Debbie Buckley-Golder (Head of Research Engagement, Innovate UK); Deirdre Glenn (Director Manufacturing, Engineering &Energy Commercialisation, Enterprise Ireland) and Yasemin Koc (Innovation Advisor, British Council).

In the UK context we heard about the Research Councils’ commitment to accelerating innovation from the UK’s excellent research base. This includes ensuring that research expertise and outcomes are accessible to business and others, as well as driving an innovation culture. The Councils and Innovate UK are working together to develop shared objectives that ensure research and innovation support is effectively dovetailed. The UK Government recognises the vital role that the commercialisation of research and new technologies play in enabling economic growth, with Innovate UK funding, supporting and connecting innovative business to enable this to happen.

In Ireland, the economy is characterised by a high percentage of SMEs and entrepreneurs, and there is a strong Government mandate to drive innovation and research commercialisation. This has helped to support recovery following the economic crisis. We heard how Enterprise Ireland provides a toolkit to support these processes. The agency also works with academics and industry to develop solutions of relevance to industry, supported by a central technology transfer office (KTI), the first of its kind in Europe.

More widely, we heard how the British Council is working in many countries across the arts, education, research and innovation to enable capacity building and support international collaboration. Programmes such as the Newton Fund are supporting innovation in emerging countries. The Council’s approach is organic and holistic, including social and policy work to understand how culture impacts on innovation.

All speakers emphasised that innovation is not a linear process. Realisation requires the right people and relationships. Successful Government support is not only about money, and sharing risk, but also catalysing sustainable, connected partnerships and activities whatever the innovation system and country context.

‘It’s all about the people!’

A copy of the presentation used in this session is available online: https://ke.org.uk/resources/presentations.asp

Home > Government

In this talk, Professor Reid explored why there has been such a focus in recent years on reviewing university-business collaborations. The talk included:

  • A review of reviews
  • A review of what was reviewed
  • How to answer the question "why are there so many reviews of university-business interaction?"

Following the Lambert Review in 2003 to 2006, there was a pretty orderly progress of policy development, but then there was an explosion of reviews following the general election in 2010. These were commissioned by Government, or linked organisations, and analysed by a variety of sector commentators. NCUB’s analysis showed that the nine reviews carried out in the 5 year period 2010-15 generated 297 recommendations.

When those recommendations were analysed, NCUB found that only 3% of the recommendations were addressed to business, and 11% to universities. That means that a massive 86% of recommendations were addressed to communities other than the ones under review. Analysis of the categories of recommendations drew more serious observations. The recommendations were not, in the main, about resources, but behaviours and organisation: not about finance, but about human behaviour.

The statistic on the sheer volume of recommendations, and who they were directed to, clearly chimed with the audience who asked how many recommendations had been acted upon. In response, Graeme Reid highlighted that it was very difficult to attribute actions to recommendations. Some are straightforward, such as the creation of NCUB; some are attributable but not necessarily causal; for others it is impossible to tell.

In terms of their intended audience, it’s true to say that government is probably generally nervous about making recommendations on how business should behave but this makes questioning and calling to account the demand side difficult, and naturally shifts the focus to the supply side and how it can do things “better” or differently, when in fact the evidence show that things are generally going well.

At this point I was also reminded of David Bott’s depiction of the decline in corporate R&D labs, made earlier in the day, and a comment that corporate investment had shifted from R&D to innovation. What was under review during the 2010-15 period was far from a static landscape. The impact agenda matured during this period and there were many reports written on impact.

For the Knowledge Exchange and Commercialisation community, the REF changed the landscape quite profoundly because it brought research and commercialisation activities together and raised their profile, collectively. The REF created a library of material that we are still learning how to mine. But putting the impact agenda into longer context, and looking at HE-BCI data on the income generated by KEC activities, we can see that the REF impact agenda in fact just reinforced activity, and drew people into a longer-term upwards trend. What will be interesting to see is whether future years’ data reflects greater shifting of ground as a result of REF activity (i.e. will we see a more dramatic increase in the HE-BCI income data post REF 2014?).

Graeme Reid made two other comments on current activity. One was that spin-outs are a commercial reality for many UK universities, and UK universities have many success stories to tell. The hard question is whether we are able to grow these spin-outs into sizeable operations, rather than letting them be bought out by other companies? The second comment concerned a trend in UK universities to build transactional relationships in to large scale strategic relationships – of the type that will support infrastructure as well as fund research.

As a result of all this activity and trends, the UK is well regarded internationally. The World Economic Forum ranking for university-business R&D collaboration has shown the UK rising into a top 5 position in recent years. An MIT Skoltech survey puts the UK 2nd to the US in terms of university-business activity, and the Global Innovation Index too sees UK climbing steadily up rankings. These rankings can only demonstrate a vibrant, high-performing KEC community.

So, there is no easy answer to the question – but there are some theories: – in 2010, there was a shift from government targets (under Labour) to reviews (under the coalition). – that there is perhaps some lazy thinking going on. It’s all too easy to find people who will complain but objective evidence doesn’t support opinion. – that reviews are a device for government to exert control over the autonomous university sector?

This latter theory can probably be discounted, because the people chosen to do the reviews were independently minded and unlikely to deliver comfortable messages to government. – that KEC has evolved from a specialist back-office function activity, into something that has quite a high public profile. Because, partly, of the REF impact agenda there is noticeably more press coverage of contribution of science/research to the economy.

As a consequence we’re seeing the development of a small function, into a prominent one. Naturally this brings it to attention of people in the political sphere, who ask more questions, and ask for more reviews to answer them. For Graeme Reid, there remains a challenge in terms of the gap between performance and reputation: these are not aligned and it remains easy to find a business person, or senior academic, who will openly criticise university-business interactions and TTOs.

At the same time, TTOs have become one actor among many actors in the innovation “ecosystem” rather than being a single actor in specialised field. So who are the advocates for KEC now? How do we overcome the challenge of performance vs reputation? What the profession needs is senior opinion advocates who will speak up for KEC. It needs to be done by practitioners’ friends, not practitioners themselves, and they need to be engaged in creating the evidence and challenging the naysayers.

A copy of Professor Graeme Reid's presentation is available at https://ke.org.uk/resources/presentations.asp

Home > Government

At PraxisUnico, we work to advocate the views of our members, to make sure they are represented on issues which affect them. But how do we come up with these responses?

The first point of contact is often our Policy Officer, Tamsin Mann. Tamsin works to keep abreast of the latest developments and ensure we are well-placed and well-informed to respond. Tamsin will often be the first to hear about consultations through her contacts, or either she or another member of PraxisUnico will be contacted directly by e.g. BIS, HEFCE or another review body for our input.

We also rely on our expert practitioners sharing information to keep us up to date, as a vital source of intelligence. Tamsin works very closely with our Advocacy committee, which is made up of highly experienced practitioners from across a range of universities and PSREs. Each member of the Advocacy committee gives up their time to contribute their views and provide direction, to ensure that a balanced and rigorous agenda is pursued on behalf of our membership. When calls such as the Dowling Review comes in, a lead contact on the Committee is appointed, to work with Tamsin in shaping the response.

In the case of the Dowling Review, that person was David Hartley, Commercial & Knowledge Transfer Manager of Oxford Brookes University. David has worked at a senior level in the private, public and not-for-profit sectors, including oversight of publicly funded schemes for business support, and now manages Oxford Brookes’ commercialisation and knowledge transfer projects across a wide range of technical and professional sectors.

Tamsin's knowledge of the policy landscape and David's experience of technology and knowledge transfer shape an initial response, which is then circulated to the rest of the Advocacy Committee. The Committee's comments and critiques are then incorporated into further revised versions, until a fully considered and representative response is achieved.< The response is then submitted to the Review Panel, and circulated to members for their information.

All PraxisUnico consultations are stored on our website for reference, as are full lists of all Committee Members. If you'd like to get involved with PraxisUnico and shape the Advocacy agenda, please get in touch by emailing tamsin.mann@praxisunico.org.uk.

Knowledge Exchange Logo
Quick Links
  • About Us
  • What is KE?
  • KE Connect
  • Jobs Board
  • Contact
Membership
  • Why join us?
  • Become a member
  • Members Directory
  • Member events
CPD
  • Training Courses
  • In-House Training
  • Workshops
  • Become a Volunteer
  • Course Trainers
  • Moodle LMS
Events
  • Conference
  • KE Awards
  • Directors’ Forum
  • Events
Legal
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Events T & C
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies
Follow Us
© Knowledge Exchange UK 2026 | Co. Registration no. 05090806 | VAT no. GB292701793
Membership Website Design | Douglass Digital

Subscribe to our Newsletters

Sign up to the Knowledge Exchange UK newsletter for for news, training, jobs and event updates.

First Name:*
Last Name:*
Email:*
Organisation:*
Job Title:*