Content Category: Impact
The report The nature, scale and beneficiaries of research impact launched at a conference hosted by HEFCE at the Royal Society. This report provides an initial assessment of the 6,679 non-redacted impact case studies that were submitted to the 2014 Research Excellence Framework (REF). A novel mix of text-mining techniques and qualitative analysis was used to synthesize the corpus of case studies. In order to help digest the large amount of data generated, a series of data visualizations are presented in the main body of the report. The headline findings from the analysis include: The societal impact of research from UK Higher Education Institutions is considerable, diverse and fascinating
- The research underpinning societal impacts is multidisciplinary, and the social benefit arising from research is multi-impactful
- Different types of Higher Education Institutions specialize in different types of impact
- UK Higher Education Institutions have a global impact
- The quantitative evidence supporting claims for impact was diverse and inconsistent, suggesting that the development of robust impact metrics is unlikely
- The impact case studies provide a rich resource for analysis, but the information is collected for assessment purposes and may need to be aligned for analysis purposes
The analysis presented in this report was performed at King’s College London. In addition to the report, Digital Science developed and produced an online searchable database (http://impact.ref.ac.uk/casestudies) of the impact case studies submitted to REF 2014, that is freely available in a form and format that will enable any researcher to carry out future analysis.
Alongside the release of the analysis of the case studies, HEFCE are also publishing an evaluation of how universities prepared their impact submissions for REF 2014. This includes a cost estimate for the exercise (see http://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR1032.html for report).
With thanks to our colleagues at King’s College London for providing this summary.
The Impact Awards recognise the outstanding contribution of knowledge exchange, knowledge transfer and/or commercialisation activities for:
- Contribution to Business
- Contribution to Society
- Outstanding KEC initiative
- International contribution
If you've got a project you think qualifies for one of these categories, make sure you can answer these four questions with a resounding "yes" before submitting your entry: (more…)
The positive impact of innovation on commercial success has long been recognised. Maintaining close ties with the research base helps businesses stay ahead of curve by exploiting the latest technological advances and getting scientific developments to the end user more quickly.
UK investment in R&D is fairly low when compared to similar countries but must contend with questions of how to best spend money from the public coffers. The question in this case is whether the money invested in public support for innovation is reaping the benefits desired, and creating new commercial success?
A recent report from the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills, on ‘estimating the effect of UK direct public support for innovation’ sought to find out just that. The report, perhaps unsurprisingly, found that firms benefit significantly from active engagement with universities or Public Sector Research Establishments (PSREs). Businesses that cooperate with universities or PSREs are 70% more likely to generate revenue from the sale of new products relative to a control group composed of firms with the same characteristics and history but who failed to make use of such institutions.
Similarly, R&D intensity (R&D as a fraction of turnover) increased by 160%[1] The National Physical Laboratory (NPL) is the UK‘s National Measurement Institute and one of the UK’s leading Public Sector Research Establishments (PSREs), and therefore serves as a good example of what public sector collaboration can offer for companies. A recent customer survey found that companies that working closely with NPL receive direct financial benefits worth £634M a year, with 63% of collaborators having introduced a new product or developing an existing one during the period of the collaboration. Over the next few years NPL is committed to increasing this to deliver £1 billion a year of financial benefit to organisations.
The most significant impacts for companies of working with NPL came through tangible products to companies, such as training, following which 92 % of organisations saw improvements in their organisations. Technical services too, provide value. As part of its Product Verification Programme, for example, NPL works with companies to optimise their processes. Product verification services account for between 10% and 20% of the cost of finished products so improving these activities can have a significant impact on production and revenues. In one instance, NPL saved a UK business a potential £500,000 risk by using a thermal imaging method called 'pulsed thermography' to reveal invisible problems with its turbine blade coatings and prevent a failure shutting down their power station.
Like many PSREs, NPL also contributes innovations at an early stage, teaming up with companies to conduct cutting edge research and help get innovative productsto market more quickly andaids sales and marketing and help build customer confidence in products, by providing third party validation. As well as improving revenue through their own products and services, the BIS report found that companies that collaborate with research institutes were more likely to secure funding through public sector grants. 45% of grant-holders also collaborated with the public sector, whilst 32% of firms that collaborated with universities and government agencies were also grant-holders. Grants support the broader development of firms’ absorptive capacity (the ability to innovate as captured in the skills, networks and experience of its people).
Companies receiving public sector grants substantially increased UK firms’ innovation performance, in a number of categories. Collaboration and public sector support made thesegroups more likely to invest more in R&D (122%), employ high-level STEM graduates (29%) and introduce novel products to market (41%). Receiving a public sector grant doubles a company’s spending on innovation. Some would argue that this would mean the company itself relies on this funding and doesn’t funding innovation itself. i.e. that public funding ‘crowds-out’ private funding.
However, the report found that the opposite was true, with public funding crowding-in around 30% more private funding (in addition to the public funding provided) across three years. There is of course more work to be done to assess all of the impacts, of collaboration over the long-term.
However, all evidence points towards the fact that public support and grants have a positive impact on UK innovation and subsequent economic growth. Companies who forge ties with universities and public sector research establishments, like NPL, can gain significantly from these partnerships, both financially and otherwise, giving them the edge over the competition. [1] The focus of this study was to look at the effects of public support for innovation. The estimates of the size of these effects have significant uncertainty e.g. R&D intensity (R&D as a fraction of turnover) increased by 160% ± 30%.
These awards recognise the important contribution made by KEC professionals working with researchers in turning excellent research or capabilities into real-life benefits and enables the sharing of best practice in KEC amongst the communities served by the Research Councils and PraxisUnico, and replace the PraxisUnico Impact Awards and BBSRC Activating Impact Awards.
Last year's PraxisUnico impact awards included Asalus Medical Instruments, and an international collaboration between University of Wolverhampton and the University of Maiduguri in Northern Nigeria. Previous winners have included Circassia, The University of Bath in collaboration with Ford Motor Company, Novacem and many more.
You can find some of the winning case studies here.
The awards are open from February 16th and close on April 16th. The shortlist will be announced at our conference in June.
A view on the REF process from Malcolm Skingle, PraxisUnico board members and Director of Academic Liaison at GSK.
(more…)