Content Category: WIPO

During November I was able to attend two events in Bangkok, looking at Knowledge and Technology Transfer. It brought together 41 people from 27 national associations for Knowledge and Technology Transfer to share best practice.
This is indicative of the global interest in supporting innovation ecosystems and the central and the evolving role of TTOs in creating economic and societal value. The first was the annual Knowledge and Technology Transfer Leadership Summit, jointly organised by AUTM and WIPO.
We heard a keynote from Marco M. Alemán, WIPO’s Assistant Director General for IP and Innovation Ecosystems, underlining the importance of on building knowledge-led transfer for institutional and ecosystem impact.
Shared principles and approaches in Global Technology Transfer:
I had the privilege of moderating an international panel on creating effective technology transfer, with contributions from Italy, New Zealand, and the USA. We explored new approaches anchored around:
- 6Ps: propositions (ideas) people, programmes, places, pounds (money) and policies.
- 3Ds: demand/pull, development/translation, defining the third mission.
- 2Cs: community and connection, with Kathy Ku, who ran the Stanford TTO for 20 years underling the value of national associations.
Furthermore there continues to be a great deal of interest in the UKs approach to spin outs following the government review. Mainly, due to the subsequent progress we have made on the spin-out register, shared TTOs, equity position and university-investor relations.
We also heard the WIPO share their thoughts on an institutional competency framework. Which I am happy to say relates strongly to the ideas already being deployed in the UK with our metrics work, Knowledge Exchange Framework and KE Concordat.
The second event was the WIPO Thailand Innovation Policy Forum which was a reminder of the power of national communities coming together to share best practice and build a common understanding of how to deliver innovation in their own context.
I was invited to moderate a panel on: “What constitutes an appropriate size and quality of Knowledge/Technology Transfer Offices (K/TTOs)? Key factors and support mechanisms.”
Here’s a look at what we explored:
- What’s needed to set up and grow a TTO.
- The challenges of starting from scratch.
- How to measure success.
- The importance of training, funding, and collaboration.
What struck me most was:
- How each country tailors its approach to local culture, economy, and opportunity
- How they are all working with the same ingredients to make innovation happen, just the availability of those ingredients and the recipes used varies where you are in the world.
- How looking for a neat comparison of which country is doing best is hard as a good comparison depends on similarity in the factors above alongside the maturity of the system
In the UK, we shouldn’t take for granted the decades of progress we’ve made as demonstrated by:
- 50 years of KTPs, bringing together businesses and universities.
- 40 years of universities managing the IP arising from their research.
- 25 years of data collection at on Business and Community engagement at a national level for universities.
All in a system involving research organisations, funders, industry and investors that has evolved over that time to include a broadening of scope and to include all academic disciplines and a breadth of pathways.
Overall, the UK is well-placed to have many of the ingredients needed and a collaborative effort across funders, investors, research organisations and investors to continue to develop our ecosystem and ultimately deliver economic and social benefit through the application of ideas for impact.

Tom Flanagan, RTTP, Director, DIT Hothouse, Dublin Institute of Technology, chaired a fascinating discussion of the difference in processes for resolving disputes using mediation, arbitration and court proceedings. The panel included The Honourable Mr Justice Peter Kelly, Judge of the Court of Appeal in Ireland, formerly Judge in Charge of the Commercial Court in Ireland; Judith Schallnau, Lawyer, IP Disputes Management Section, WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Centre; David Perkins, Arbitrator / Mediator for WIPO and other international arbitration bodies. Peter Kelly described the changes to Irish commercial court procedures over the past 10 years, and how the Irish system is now on average the fastest in the EU, partly because it is proactively case managed. The Irish courts strongly advocate the use of mediation as an alternative to resolution through the courts, although they cannot impose mediation. He advised that mediation can offer solutions to issues beyond those discussed in the court case, and that this can have a positive impact for all parties involved. Judith Schallnau from WIPO described the WIPO arbitration and mediation service, and their role in facilitating both processes and in case management. She mentioned the use of mediation and arbitration in model agreements like DESCA (Horizon2020) and explained the differences between court litigation, arbitration and mediation lying in cost (mediation and arbitration are less expensive than court litigation in multiple jurisdictions) and time (mediation is much shorter than court litigation in many jurisdictions, arbitration can be tailored to meet the need for timely dispute resolution) and in the role of the mediator (facilitates communications, may make proposals while the parties determine the conduct of the mediation and terms of settlement) and the arbitrator (who decides the case). David Perkins then shared his experiences as an arbitrator and a mediator, discussing the various forms that success can take. He set his experiences against the back drop of current court procedures and the expected changes when the Unitary Patents Court (UPC) comes into being, commenting that the UPC may take many years to settle down. A great session which clearly put the importance of alternative methods of dispute resolution in the spot light together with the need to consider these at the point of contact drafting. Copies of the speaker presentations are available online: https://ke.org.uk/resources/presentations.asp

